"Nestled among Pennsylvania's rolling hills is Bird-in-Hand, a tiny village where Amish, Mennonites, and Englishers live side by side. It's here where the close-knit Classen sisters reunite after inheriting their family home—a beautiful Victorian farmhouse—with hopes of reopening their grandmother's incredibly popular gift and thrift store, Secondhand Blessings, housed in the centuries-old barn next to the house. Soon life in this quiet...

When a famous television chef and her husband drive by the old Victorian home and the barn that contains Secondhand Blessings, they are not only smitten with the place but also insistent on filming a secret episode of the chef's Dining and Décor Network cooking show there. With Mary and Martha still reeling from the news that their families are unable to travel to be with them during the holidays, and Elizabeth struggling to adapt to all the changes...

When a little Amish boy in Bird-in-Hand is diagnosed with leukemia, the Plain community rallies around him - as do Martha, Mary, and Elizabeth, and Secondhand Blessings becomes a staging area to gather donated goods for a fund-raising auction. The little boy's grandfather, Alvin Miller, donates a racehorse he recently acquired, along with a valuable saddle, to the cause. But when Alvin's stable is set on fire and both the horse and saddle disappear,...

As summer arrives, Mary and her sisters, Elizabeth and Martha, investigate the mystery of a valuable stamp that vanishes. Meanwhile, they also prepare for a family reunion, and try to create a milkweed preserve for the monarch butterflies.

"Mystery arises at Secondhand Blessings when Martha promises to hold a unique crazy quilt for her late mother's best friend Anne, who says it is a family heirloom. But then an elderly Amish customer comes along and demands that she be allowed to buy the quilt, claiming that it belonged to her family. Do the two share some connection the Classens don't know about? Can Amish neighbor Rachel Fischer help the sisters uncover the clues they need from members...

"Elizabeth Classen’s curiosity is aroused when she notices an unfamiliar teenage girl hiding pieces of fruit in her pockets from the refreshment table during the church's social hour. No one seems to know the girl, few other people observed her, and when Elizabeth tries to speak with her, the girl bolts. Who is the fruit thief? Why is she sneaking food? And how can Elizabeth help her? At home, the sisters find evidence that a thief of a different...

"When Adam Fischer--Rachel's eldest son--faces arrest for a hit-and-run and other serious crimes, the Classen sisters are sure the authorities are targeting the wrong man. Adam doesn't even drive, let alone have a credit card, such as the one used for fraud. But someone claiming to be Adam has been involved in a number of crimes, and all the evidence points to him. As Martha and her sisters, Elizabeth and Mary, learn more about Adam's past, they start...

"Elizabeth Classen is delighted when her high school sweetheart, Peter Russell, comes to town, but she quickly realizes that he's had a difficult life since he left Bird-in-Hand many years earlier. All he wants now is to reconnect with his daughter, Crystal, and get to know his teenage granddaughter, Willow. However, the gulf between father and daughter only grows wider when Crystal's valuable diamond pendant disappears and she accuses Peter of theft....

"After a near accident on icy roads in Lancaster County, Elizabeth Classen watches as a furniture truck slides through a slippery intersection and crashes! As the driver is rushed to the hospital, the police open the truck to check the damage and soon discover that the compartments of a desk inside have opened, revealing a secret stash of drugs. Could the Amish furniture store be a front for drug smuggling? Or was someone else using the store for...

"When a vintage typewriter comes into the shop, Mary is delighted to take a closer look at such a fun treasure. As she unspools the ribbon cartridge, Mary finds a clue to a fifty-year-old mystery! With the help of her sisters, Elizabeth and Martha, Mary looks into the cold case and makes some unexpected discoveries. With a long list of suspects, the Classen sisters soon realize that someone desperately wants these long-buried secrets to remain hidden....